Lawyers for Ghislaine Maxwell on Tuesday asked a New York federal appeals court to toss her conviction for aiding Jeffrey Epstein’s sexual exploitation of teenage girls — contending she was protected by a 2007 sweetheart deal between the deceased financier and the feds.
Arguing before the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, the former British socialite’s appellate lawyer, Diana Fabi Samson, said a section in Epstein’s nonprosecution deal with the Southern District of Florida covering potential coconspirators should have prohibited the feds from charging Maxwell 13 years after it was penned.
“Denying the viability of this agreement strikes a dagger in the heart of the trust between the government and its citizens regarding plea agreements,” Samson argued.
Arguing for the government, Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrew Rohrbach said the deal — which saw Epstein dodge meaningful responsibility a decade before his 2019 arrest and suicide — didn’t stop New York prosecutors from bringing charges.
“The central promise in the nonprosecution agreement is a promise by the Southern District of Florida not to prosecute Epstein in that district,” Rohrbach said. It is not clear which potential coconspirators were named in the document.
Judge Raymond Lohier asked Rorbach whether he knew of any similar deal binding every federal prosecutor’s office in the country. Rohrbach said he didn’t and described any reference to “United States” in Epstein’s deal as “generic.”
“It says nothing about the national scope,” Rohrbach said.
Ghislaine Maxwell
Elizabeth Williams/AP In this courtroom sketch, Ghislaine Maxwell givers her statement in federal court, in New York on June 28, 2022. (Elizabeth Williams/AP)
Maxwell, 63, was found guilty of a litany of sex crimes in December 2021, including transporting a minor for illegal sex acts, sex trafficking a minor, and related conspiracy counts. She was later sentenced to 20 years in prison.
Evidence at the Manhattan federal court trial revealed how the multilingual, Oxford-educated daughter of a publishing baron — who introduced Epstein to the likes of her old school pal Prince Andrew — acted as the Brooklyn-born multimillionaire predator’s “lady of the house” for at least a decade beginning in 1994, procuring disadvantaged teens and young women for him to abuse around-the-clock under the guise of receiving massages, some of which she participated in.
Her summer 2020 arrest came about a year after Epstein killed himself at Manhattan’s now-shuttered Metropolitan Correctional Center while awaiting trial. Maxwell has long claimed prosecutors scapegoated her with egg on their faces after losing a high-profile inmate.
Epstein’s second arrest on sex trafficking charges carrying the potential for decades in prison came after a bombshell report by The Miami Herald accused him of abusing dozens of young girls in plain sight at his properties worldwide for decades, including at his Palm Beach mansion, private Caribbean Island, and Upper East Side townhouse, where he hosted some of the world’s most famous names.
The highly unusual non-prosecution agreement afforded him by former U.S. Attorney Alexander Acosta allowed him to plead guilty in a state court in 2008 to soliciting a 14-year-old for sex and to leave jail for work during his 13-month sentence.
Police records unsealed in a related lawsuit in January detailed how Palm Beach police had identified up to 33 girls recruited for his abuse around the time Acosta offered him the deal.
The appeals court panel did not indicate when it would rule.
